Italian restaurants

Pepino's Restaurant

4.5 1,067 reviews 11:00 AM - 08:00 PM 2410 Ontario, Schererville, IN 46375, United States

Discover this place

Pepino's Restaurant in Schererville, IN, is quickly becoming a local favorite for Italian cuisine, garnering rave reviews from patrons. The welcoming atmosphere and friendly staff consistently enhance the dining experience, as noted by customer Benjamin Moffitt, who praised not only the exceptional food but also the reasonable prices. The menu features standout dishes like the enormous Italian Beef sandwich, highlighted by Chris Freeman for its generous portions and flavorful spicy giardiniera, making it a must-try for meat lovers.

Braulio Robles echoed this sentiment, enjoying the combo beef and sausage and noting the perfect char and substantial leftovers—a true testament to the generous servings at Pepino's. Julie Martin, a longtime fan, assures newcomers that the quality has remained stellar over the course of 35 years, guaranteeing a satisfying meal every visit. Ricky Knudsen's equally enthusiastic feedback underscores the restaurant’s commitment to excellence, with quick service and hearty portions earning them top marks.

From its delectable sandwiches to its vibrant atmosphere, Pepino's Restaurant proves that high-quality Italian cuisine is both accessible and worth returning to time and again.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Outdoor seating
Curbside pickup
Drive-through
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in
Delivery

Highlights

Fast service
Great dessert
Serves local specialty

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Counter service
Dessert
Seating

Amenities

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual
Cozy
Quiet

Crowd

Groups
Tourists

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Pepino's Restaurant before visiting.

Reviews for Pepino's Restaurant

4.5

1,067 reviews

100%

20%

10%

Review highlights

Based on 1,067 reviews

Pepino's Restaurant in Schererville consistently receives praise for its generous portions and authentic Italian flavors, particularly their Italian beef and sausage offerings. Reviewers frequently highlight the quality and taste of the food, noting flavorful meats and well-balanced seasonings that satisfy both regulars and newcomers alike. The atmosphere is described as welcoming, complemented by friendly and attentive staff who contribute to a pleasant dining experience. Many customers appreciate the reasonable pricing paired with hearty meals, making Pepino's a favored stop for both quick bites and casual dining. Although minor preferences on spiciness vary, overall feedback underscores the restaurant's consistent quality and positive service, fostering a loyal customer base that values its longstanding reputation in the community.

Benjamin Moffitt

Jul 12, 2025

I've had Pepino's twice now and have been extremely satisfied with each aspect of their restaurant. The staff is friendly, the food is phenominal and and the price point is not too bad. I never knew it was here before my coworkers showed it to me and I look forward to trying the rest of their menu!

Chris Freeman

Jul 10, 2025

The Italian Beef at Pepinos Schererville was huge! Ample amounts of thinly sliced beef with with a unique spicy giardiniera that included green olives. I would’ve liked to have been a little spicier, but it was fine and the jus was good. This was a banger of a sandwich and I would definitely order it again. The staff who assisted me with my purchase were very attentive and nice.

Braulio Robles

Jun 24, 2025

Got the combo beef and sausage with the works. Great tastes- beef flavor, char on sausage, just right roll- and portions are made for leftovers. Will definitely be a return guest ...

Julie Martin

Jun 07, 2025

We love Pepinos and anytime we are near them, we stop to eat. It's as good today as it was 35 years ago.

Ricky Knudsen

May 27, 2025

Place is phenomenal. Italian beef sandwich has so much meat on it that you could order an additional bun and make 2 sandwiches. The service was quick and pleasant. No rain for anything less then five stars.

Ashourrina Auz

May 22, 2025

Love it here. I recently moved closer and now I’m going even more often! The portions for the prices are unreal! I’m so impressed. Everything that comes out of the kitchen looks and smells amazing. My favorite dinner is the stuffed shells but I’ll come regularly for a slice of pizza too. I love that they have a little bit of everything. Great and friendly service and I never have to wait long. Kitchen is very efficient!

Eric Ball

Apr 04, 2025

Holy cow, if you like Itilian beef, you have to try this restaurant. I had the itilian beef itilian sausage combo, and it was the best itilian beef I have ever had. On top of that, the fries are fresh cut and just as good. Great out of the way spot that I found. The staff was really friendly and recommended the food to me. I will definitely be returning again!! If you go there to eat, you're going to put on about 10 pounds with their portions, but it is worth it!

TJB Show (TJB Show)

Mar 22, 2025

Awesome Roast Beef good pricing friendly staff